Which passage provides most effective argument and why

We need to see a picture of the passages

Explanation:

You don't have a picture of the passages so we can't see what one provides the most effective argument

The third-person point of view used by Sinclair is intended to achieve his resolution, by focusing on what Jurgis understands and feels. The narrator concentrates on the main character Jurgis, his emotions and his thoughts, and the readers also get an perception on other minor characters’ thought processes.